The click feels like the decision. It is not.
By the time a customer clicks your ad, the real decision has already been made or it has not. What happens between first exposure and that click, the research, the consideration, the moments of doubt and reassurance, is where purchase decisions are genuinely formed. And most D2C brands are spending the majority of their attention on the last few seconds of a journey that began much earlier.
This article answers a question that matters enormously for D2C brands: where do purchase decisions actually happen, and what should brands be doing about it?
Content
What Is the Messy Middle of the Purchase Journey?
Google has spent years researching what happens between the moment a consumer first becomes aware of a product and the moment they buy it. What they found challenges the assumption that purchase journeys are tidy, linear progressions from awareness to consideration to conversion.
The reality is what Google calls the Messy Middle: a complex, non-linear space between triggers and purchase where customers explore and evaluate, cycling through these two modes repeatedly before committing. This is where customers are won and lost. Not at the ad. Not at checkout. In the middle, during all the moments in between.
In a large-scale experiment simulating 310,000 purchase scenarios, Google found that even a fictional brand with zero prior exposure could win 28% of shopper preference from an established favourite, simply by being present with the right information and the right signals at the right moment in that journey. The brand that shows up most effectively during the consideration process, not the one that spends most at the point of purchase, wins more customers.
Why Consumer Confidence Drives Purchase Decisions
Google’s Messy Middle research found that purchase confidence is 3.2 times higher among consumers who feel they found relevant information during their journey. Confident customers are not just more likely to convert. They are 6 times more likely to buy again and 18 times more likely to recommend the brand to others.
This reframes what marketing is actually trying to do. It is not simply about reaching people. It is about building the confidence that moves someone from consideration to commitment. That confidence is built across a series of moments, not in a single ad.
For D2C brands, this matters because the products that require the most confidence to buy, premium items, subscriptions, anything with a longer consideration cycle, are precisely the ones where the journey between trigger and purchase is longest and most influenced by what the brand does, or fails to do, during that window.
Where Does the Purchase Journey Actually Start?
TikTok’s own research reveals that 83% of shoppers say they have discovered a new product on TikTok Shop, and 70% have discovered a new brand. The platform’s data also shows that 63% of consumers need to see content at least three to four times before making a purchase, and 85% switch apps at some point during their purchase journey.
That final statistic is the one most brands have not fully absorbed. 85% of consumers are moving between platforms during a single purchase journey. They discover on one platform, research on another, validate on a third, and only then convert. The idea that a customer sees your ad and buys in a single session is the exception, not the rule.
TikTok describes this as the challenge of the messy mid-funnel: the space between discovery and conversion where brands are most at risk of losing a customer to a competitor, a distraction, or simply a moment of hesitation. The brands that show up consistently and relevantly across that mid-funnel period are the ones that close the gap between interest and action.
What Role Does Meta Play in the D2C Purchase Journey?
Meta’s platforms sit at the heart of the social discovery journey. BCG’s most recent Global Consumer Radar research found that 40% of Gen Z starts their purchase research on Instagram or TikTok, making Meta’s flagship visual platform one of the primary entry points into the consideration cycle for younger premium consumers. Sprout Social’s research supports this, finding that over a quarter of social users from every generation turn to Instagram to discover their next purchase.
BCG’s broader research also found that approximately 50% of consumers approach a purchase without a predetermined brand preference, with 43% actively wanting to research and compare their options before deciding. That open, undecided majority is precisely the audience that social discovery platforms like Instagram and Facebook are best positioned to reach and influence.
Meta’s surfaces are visual, social, and algorithmically designed to surface relevant content in the moments people are most open to discovery. For D2C brands, this means Meta is not simply a performance channel for closing sales. It is a discovery and consideration channel where preference is shaped, often well before any purchase intent is explicit. Treating it purely as a conversion tool means entering the conversation too late.
How Does Pinterest Fit Into the Consumer Purchase Journey?
Pinterest’s model of the customer journey is built around a specific insight: people come to the platform to plan what they will do, try, or buy next. This is pre-purchase behaviour by design. The mindset of someone on Pinterest is forward-looking and open. They are not browsing idly. They are building a picture of what they want.
Research commissioned by Pinterest found that Pinterest audiences spend 26% more per trip than users of other platforms. This reflects the intent that people bring to the platform. The moment of highest receptivity to a brand is often not the moment of purchase, but the moment of aspiration that precedes it.
For D2C brands, being present at the planning moment is a different strategic proposition from being present at the buying moment. Both matter. But the planning moment is where a brand can enter someone’s consideration set before the competitive pressure of the purchase decision has fully arrived.
Why Is Social Trust So Important in Purchase Decisions?
Snapchat’s research, conducted across markets including the UK, consistently highlights one finding above all others: friends and family are the single most influential factor in consumers’ ultimate purchase decisions. 84% of Snapchatters trust brands more when recommended by someone like themselves. 86% trust a brand more when a family member recommends it.
This is not unique to Snapchat users. It reflects something fundamental about how purchase decisions are made. They are social. They are validated through the opinions of others. The conversation that takes place between a consumer and their social circle before a purchase is a critical part of the consideration process, and it is almost entirely invisible to most brands.
What this tells D2C brands is that the influence on a purchase decision often happens in spaces and conversations they cannot directly control or even see. Which makes what they can control, the clarity of their message, the relevance of their creative to the specific moment, the ease with which a customer can form and share a confident opinion, all the more important.
What Does This Mean for D2C Creative Strategy?
If purchase decisions are formed across a journey that begins long before the click, then the creative that runs at the moment of the click is not doing the persuading. It is simply being present at the conclusion of a process that happened earlier.
This changes what creative is for. Not every piece of creative needs to convert. Some of it needs to enter the consideration set at the planning moment. Some of it needs to provide the reassurance that builds confidence during the evaluation phase. Some of it needs to make the brand easy to recall and recommend when someone’s social circle starts talking about the category.
Knowing which moment a piece of creative is designed to serve changes the brief entirely. A brand that understands its customer’s journey and builds creative for each distinct stage of it is doing something fundamentally different from a brand that runs the same performance creative from awareness all the way through to conversion.
How Should D2C Brands Think About the Full Purchase Journey?
The consistent finding across Google, TikTok, Meta, Pinterest, and Snapchat’s research points in the same direction: the customer journey is non-linear, multi-platform, and heavily influenced by what happens in the spaces between the first exposure and the final click.
The brands that win are not necessarily the ones with the largest budgets or the most creative executions. They are the ones that understand which moments matter in their customer’s specific journey, and that show up with the right message at each of those moments.
That is a more precise and ultimately more profitable way to think about marketing than optimising for the last click.
The Graygency is a performance marketing agency for D2C brands. We practise True Performance Marketing to identify micro-moments, building targeted creative for those moments, and constructing growth systems that compound over time.
Sources: Google Think / The Behavioural Architects, Decoding Decisions: The Messy Middle (thinkwithgoogle.com); Google / The Behavioural Architects, First-Party Data in the Messy Middle, April 2024; TikTok Newsroom, TikTok Shop Discovery Research, GlobalData, June 2025; TikTok / BCG, Future of Commerce Study, 2022; BCG Global Consumer Radar, The Future of Influence and Brand Discovery, June 2026; BCG, Agentic Scenarios Every Marketer Must Prepare For, April 2026; Sprout Social, 2026 Social Media Content Strategy Report; Pinterest Business, LiveRamp Study, November 2025; Snapchat for Business / National Research Group, E-Commerce Attitudes and Behaviors Across the Purchase Journey, EMEA, 2024.
